Metropolitan Opera’s Craig Rutenberg fills Toronto Summer Music fellows in on the true art of the art song

Baritone Tyler Fitzgerald and pianist Nikolay Verevkin listen to Craig Rutenberg’s instruction at a public master class at the Toronto Summer Music Festival on Tuesday (John Terauds iPhone photo).

Sit back, and all you’re supposed to hear is a polished whole. But peer at the artistry with a metaphorical magnifying glass, and the amount of detail that does into singing a 2-minute art song is staggering.

The amount of finesse and nuance is “like the fine brush strokes on a Giotto,” says Craig Rutenberg after his public masterclass for the Toronto Summer Music Festival and Academy at Walter Hall on Tuesday.

The Metropolitan Opera’s director of music administration, vocal coach and seasoned accompanist had just spent nearly two-and-a-half hours patiently, insightfully and gently coaching five singers and their accompanists through two German Lieder and three French mélodies at University of Toronto’s Walter Hall.

There were no grand philosophical discussions or speeches about interpretation. Nor was there any ego on display. This was all about the little things that make the difference between an okay interpretation and one that puts the listener on the proverbial edge of their seat.

It was about breathing, about the most subtle of inflections on particular vowels, the shaping of a consonant. It was also about trying to get each singer and pianist into the right headspace — both psychologically and physiologically — to make the best sounds possible.

“Breathe through your eyes; that’s your resonance,” said the coach to more than one young singer.

“Sing with your hand,” he instructed a pianist, to try and bring the accompaniment into partnership with the vocalist. The coach also referred to the piano part not as an add-on, but the singer’s “carpet of reliability.”

Above all, Rutenberg wanted the fellows to take charge of the stage, even though what they were doing was being picked apart and refashioned by the musical veteran.

He didn’t mince words as he told one singer that their performance doesn’t have enough presence. “It doesn’t start; it happens,” is how he described the song.

“Feeling self-critical about your singing?” the coach asked rhetorically at one point. “Well, get over it.”

“How many times in life do you get to take up a lot of space on stage, and people let you do it?” he added, later.

Five songs over more than two hours seems like a lot of time on not very much. But, in reality, Rutenberg was only scratching the surface. Each singer and pianist would have easily spent the whole allotted time on their one piece of music. (His work with the Academy’s fellows continues all week.)

The best part of the exercise was witnessing how, with each fresh bit of advice and insight, each of the aspiring singers was able to clearly improve their singing and their interpretation — and each of the pianists was able to add fresh support and nuance to the result.

Rutenberg knows of what he speaks, because he has done it — and continues to do it — all.

Craig Rutenberg in action as accompanist, with baritone Thomas Hampson. Another one of his regular partners is soprano Christine Brewer.

Although Rutenberg spends much of his time immersed in the world of opera, with its larger-than-life music, gestures and singing, he doesn’t think the artistic gulf is as wide as it looks.

“So much of what a Lied singer does can also apply to opera,” he says after the masterclass. “If you look at a [Tito] Gobbi, certainly [Maria] Callas, there’s detail in every syllable.”

He adds: “I think most really great opera singers know how to bring the intimacy of the song to the operatic canvas. That’s what makes them so wonderful.” Again, he reaches into the recent past, citing Renata Scotto as an example of the complete artist.

Anyone who has spent some time hanging around fans of art song and opera has heard someone say that today’s singers just don’t engage the heart quite as tightly as the previous generation of greats did.

Asked if this is a question of finesse, Rutenberg agrees, but only partially.

“There is an acceptance of many [opera] singers these days who just sing loudly and straightforwardly and then burn out rather quickly,” says the coach. That seems to be okay with a lot of the producers, because they don’t expect it, somehow.

“There are some wonderful major voices out there,” he continues. “There are quite a few singers who get away with singing slightly sharp, or slightly flat or sometimes both at the same time. They have a wonderful presence and that allows them to get away with a certain amount of murder. It’s not my idea of how the world should work, but it’s what going on right now.

“On the other hand, you have a lot of lesser-name singers who are just dying to get the finesse and the possibilities of finesse. It’s a pure delight to work with someone like that.’

Rutenberg, who has promised not to name names, makes an exception, citing German soprano Sabine Hogrefe. Her voice is not ravishingly beautiful, “but instantly recognizable,” he says.

The pianist coached her for her début in the title role of Richard Strauss’s Elektra in Regensburg this past winter.  “She went at it like a big Strauss Lied,” smiles Rutenberg. “Can I do this? Is this allowed?” he mimics, with glee.

“Good for her. She worked her tushie off and had a huge success.”


Here, to show off the flair with which pianist and singer can work together is Rutenberg and Vivica Genaux, in “Madrid,” by Pauline Viardot-Garcia, in a live-to-air performance for WNYC two years ago:

John Terauds


6 thoughts on “Metropolitan Opera’s Craig Rutenberg fills Toronto Summer Music fellows in on the true art of the art song

  1. sounds like a worthwhile event. sorry i couldn’t take it in.

    too bad that, unlike opera, the market for artsong has virtually collapsed, at least here in toronto and by extension canada. the conservatory itself must be taken to task for the apparent demise of vocal recitals in its beautful new recital hall.

    so craig’s efforts, as compelling as they no doubt are, are an entirely academic exercise these days.

    john, we have our work cut our for us in our effforts to build, or rebuild, a market for this wonderful music.

    • Rutenberg and I talked about the merits (and problems) of singing Lieder and mélodies in English. It was done all the time before WWII, and it might be time to go back to that practice, I think, to help better connect with audiences.

      • I personally am a fan of this practice, ditto speaking (briefly and wittily) about the music from the platform. This brings the music to life for the audience and they don’t have to do all that annoying page turning as they read the translations.

    • Classes like Gerry’s and Craig’s do much to educate the vocal fan in the Art of Song. I am amazed by the hard core opera fans who fail to appreciate their favourite singers in recital! Their absence in the recital hall is puzzling.

  2. Academic? The Art Song? NEVER! I have been part of a fantastic project since 2005 which has opened my soul and mind to the intimate and personal world of the poetry and the inner world of the composers who set those poems to music. They weren’t written for the stage or concert hall but were written because. I believe, the composers were driven to express their innermost thoughts and feelings on the deepest levels.

    So they wrote songs for mostly piano and voice with no promise of performance, just wrote them because they were free to do so.
    Wrote them because they could be as intelligent as they possibly could and didn’t have to follow any regimes rules, could go to any emotion they felt, explore any idea they wanted to. That is what is possible in an *Art Song*. I think that is possible in any language and love discovering Art Songs, especially newly written ones.

    The project is the Ukrainian Art Song Project :.
    (artistic director Pavlo Hunka).

    The larger audience is in the cyber world we inhabit, the
    recordings we create, the scores that we make available to the world. Of course live performances are crucial to music but I would suggest that this world is our oyster lets get out there!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s